Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Gunnar Rundgren's avatar

Good analysis. On the pickings: It is worth noting that Trump just signed and EO declaring phosphorous fertilizer and glyphosate as essential for national security. That is quite a blow to MAHA.

On the EU meat subsidies. I find the headline and text very misleading. The overwhelming part of EU subsidies are paid per hectare regardless if the crop is used for feed, seed, food, biofuel or industrial purposes. To recalculate this support according to dubious figures of how much of EU crop production end up as feed (which is not the same as it is grown for feed) and call it subsidies for meat is not very serious. In addition, as the production of legumes is very small to compare the total sum spent on those crops with the total of the erroneously calculated support to meat is misleading.

The reality is that if you are a farmer with a certain acreage you get the same basic support per hectare - but in addition, most (not all) EU member states have extra area support for legumes. Apart from grazing support (which is for biodiversity and not for meat production) there are, to my knowledge (there are some national variations in the application of EU support) no special area support directed to meat production. There is however some other direct support, decided on the nation state level for certain kinds of livestock production, but these support is a smaller share of the support.

In addition, most legumes are used as feed so you will have a real mess in the numbers.

One can make similar objections to the statement that "Dairy, meanwhile, received 554 times more in subsidies than nuts and seeds.".

The plants are good, animals are bad binary is tiresome and has very little grounding in the realities of farming. There are agro-ecological reasons for why every agricultural and food system - ever - has included both plants and animals, with proportions decided by the ecological condition.

Sam Green's avatar

Really, really good read. Thank you for sharing!

No posts

Ready for more?